Senior Resistance to Care & Support

When they are ready for support, it may be too late...
March 20, 2019
Latest news

Caring for a senior loved one who lives alone can come with challenges. One of the toughest challenges arises when older adults and their children aren’t on the same page about the “what and when” of aging support needed. Sometimes, then, by the time the senior adult is ready for support, there’s been a crisis (e.g., a fall), and they need a higher level of care than can be provided in-home.

To assist with overcoming resistance to getting the help that can extend independence at home, communication is key. Having an honest conversation allows you to express your thoughts and worries, and allows your senior loved one to express theirs, as well; it’s important to actively listen to their concerns. Some additional thoughts to keep in mind can help you both:

     1. Senior care services do not have to be an “all-or-none” approach. Suggest a          trial!

     2. Be ready to compromise; don’t dig in your heels on the small details; rather,          keep in mind the big picture. 

     3. Keep your loved one involved in the decision-making process as much as          possible. As in all aspects of our lives, we are usually more accepting and          comfortable about receiving help and support when we’re involved in the          decisions.

Here are some questions to help identify older adult service needs and thoughts about how to discuss them:

     1. Have they recently experienced a decline in physical ability, mental          cognition, the loss of a loved one or independence? 

     2. Why may they be resistant to some support? Are they feeling vulnerable to          these changes? Do they see it as an intrusion? A loss of independence rather          than a support to their independence? Do they feel guilty about the financial          burden on you? Think about how you might address all of these very valid          feelings before you start the conversation. 

     3. What is the appropriate level of care needed? In your opinion, what level of          care do they need? For example, do they need someone checking in at          home? Simple daily or weekly phone check-ins? Would a weekly video chat          with a master’s prepared health “partner” be of benefit? What level of care          do you feel they would be accepting of? Would they be willing to try a          particular service to prevent needing one they are resistant to? You may not          be able to meet all their wishes, but it is important to keep them all in          consideration.

     4. Is there someone who can help you with this conversation? Are there          family or friends that can help you have this conversation with your loved          one? Or someone close who they’d be more apt to listen to than you? Would          it be easier to have this conversation with their physician present?

     5. What’s the best way to have this conversation? This can be quite a difficult          conversation; it can cause a host of emotions, including agitation and fear. It          may be appropriate to spread out the conversation over a period of time. Try          to keep your own worries from escalating the tone of the conversation, and          your loved one’s fears in mind; and let them know that the goal for both of          you is to come up with the least intrusive but most effective way to keep          them independent at home as long as possible, if that’s what they’d like.


[i] US Census Bureau. "OlderAmericans Month: May 2016." Older Americans Month: May 2016. August 15,2016.

[ii] Chopik, William J. "TheBenefits of Social Technology Use Among Older Adults Are Mediated by ReducedLoneliness." Cyberpsychology,Behavior, and Social Networking19, no. 9 (September 1, 2016): 551-56.doi:10.1089/cyber.2016.0151.

[iii] Oconnor, M., H. Fuller, andF. Cortez. "Technology Use Among Older Adults In Rural Areas." Innovation in Aging2, no. Suppl_1 (November 11,2018): 679. doi:10.1093/geroni/igy023.2528.

[iv] Vaportzis, Eleftheria, MariaGiatsi Clausen, and Alan J. Gow. "Older Adults Perceptions of Technologyand Barriers to Interacting with Tablet Computers: A Focus GroupStudy." Frontiersin Psychology8 (October 04, 2017). doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01687.

[v] Tech Adoption Climbs Among Older Adults.Report. May 17, 2017.

[vi] Anderson, Oscar. Technology Use and Attitudes among Mid-Lifeand Older Americans.Report. December 2017.

[vii] Designing Technology for the AgingPopulation.Report. School of Gerontology, USC Leonard Davis.

[viii]Sarmah-Hightower, Satta."These Companies Make Remote Monitoring For Seniors Less Intrusive."Resources. March 12, 2018.

[ix] Carr, Julie, RN."Remote Monitoring in Geriatric Care." Today's Geriatric Medicine, November/December 2015,26.

[x] Asch, David A., Ralph W.Muller, and Kevin G. Volpp. "Automated Hovering in Health Care — WatchingOver the 5000 Hours." NewEngland Journal of Medicine367, no. 1 (2012): 1-3. doi:10.1056/nejmp1203869.

[xi] Evans, Jarrett, AmyPapadopoulos, Christine Tsien Silvers, Neil Charness, Walter R. Boot, LorettaSchlachta-Fairchild, Cindy Crump, Michele Martinez, and Carrie Beth Ent."Remote Health Monitoring for Older Adults and Those with Heart Failure:Adherence and System Usability." Telemedicine and E-Health22, no. 6 (2016): 480-88.doi:10.1089/tmj.2015.0140.